Who will be the legal guardian if something happens to us?

Let’s be real: no one wakes up excited to think about worst-case scenarios. But part of becoming a parent means stepping into a new kind of courage, the kind that protects your child even if you're not around to do it yourself.

If something were to happen to both of you, who would raise your child? Who would guide them, love them, and keep them safe?

That’s what choosing a legal guardian is all about.

Choose someone who reflects your values

Think of the qualities that matter most to you as a parent. What do you hope your child absorbs from growing up in your home? Kindness? Spirituality? Grit? Empathy? Academic drive? Deep belly laughs?

Now ask: who else in your life lives those values?

A shared belief system and parenting style can make all the difference, especially in a time of grief and transition. Children thrive in consistency. The more aligned your guardian is with your worldview, the less disruption your child may feel.

Prioritize emotional and financial stability

Raising a child is hard. Raising someone else’s child, especially after a loss, can be even harder. That’s why it’s essential to choose someone who is:

• Emotionally steady (someone who can show up in tough moments without falling apart)

• Financially secure (or willing to work with the support you’ve set aside, like life insurance or a trust)

• Mature enough to juggle routines, doctor visits, school applications, and all the invisible parenting labor you know so well

Think long-term, but not forever

You don’t need to find someone who will parent your child from kindergarten through college. That’s impossible to predict. Choose the best fit for the next few years based on your child’s age, your potential guardian’s life stage, and what your family needs today.

And then revisit the decision every few years. Your child will grow. So will your relationships. Adjust as needed.

Consider age and health, too

Your parents might’ve been great at raising you, but will they have the stamina to keep up with your child in five or ten years? Will they be in good health when your child hits high school?

It’s not just about love; it’s about timing, too. If you choose older guardians, consider naming backups and giving your primary choice the option to step aside gracefully if needed.

Location, location, location

Would your child have to move to a different city? Change schools? Leave behind their community?

That’s not necessarily a dealbreaker, but location affects every part of a child’s life: friendships, academics, extracurriculars, even culture. Look for someone whose environment feels like a continuation of the life you’ve already built.

Bond matters

A pre-existing relationship with your child can help ease the transition and provide comfort in a confusing time. If your child already sees the guardian as a safe, loving adult, that trust becomes a bridge through grief.

And if your child is older, ask for their input. They may not get final say, but their comfort and voice still count.

Logistics

Here’s what many people overlook (and regret later):

• Have an open conversation. Don’t surprise someone with guardianship in your will. Talk to them about it: what it means, what support you’ve arranged, and what they’d be taking on.

• Name backups. At least two or three. Life is unpredictable. Your first choice may not be available when the time comes.

• Separate the roles if needed. Consider naming a custodial guardian (who raises your child) and a financial guardian (who manages any assets or inheritance). It’s okay if your most nurturing friend isn’t your most fiscally responsible one.

• Create temporary guardianship instructions. If you’re ever hospitalized, who can legally care for your child overnight? Appointing short-term guardians can prevent a child from ending up in state custody while the system figures things out.

• Use a confidential exclusion letter if there’s someone you absolutely don’t want raising your child, even if they’re family. You don’t need to share it widely, but make sure someone trustworthy knows where it is.

You don’t have to make a perfect choice, just a loving one

You are your child’s ideal parent (well... my sister claims she is our daughter’s favorite). No one can replace you. But someone can honor what you’ve built, offer safety, and love your child through whatever comes next.

‍